30 White Elephant Gifts Everyone Will Want to Steal—All Under $25 at Target

Every year, my family does a huge white elephant gift exchange with aunts, uncles, and cousins all participating. Sometimes it’s planned with a theme in mind and, without fail, always consists of a battle over the best present. This tradition isn’t unique to my family—many holiday gatherings include some type of gift exchange. So if you’re anything like me and already feeling the pressure of getting an item worth fighting for, I stumbled across the perfect place to find one.

Target’s hidden gift shop has hundreds of ideas—from skincare sets and satin pillowcases to travel gear and heated shoulder massagers—all under $25. Below, I rounded up the 30 white elephant gifts to grab for this year’s exchange before they’re gone.  

30 Best White Elephant Gifts at Target 

• Peter Thomas Roth Masking Minis Skincare Set, $19
• A New Day 14K Gold Plated Duo Herringbone Chain Necklace Set, $25
• Brightroom Small Travel Accessory Organizer, $15
• Burt’s Bees Three-Piece Kissable Color Warm Gift Set, $15
• Simple Modern 24-Ounce Stainless Steel Classic Tumbler, $20
• A New Day Small Zip Wallet, $10
• Very Glossy Lip Gloss Gift Set, $10
• Quip Plastic Electric Toothbrush Starter Kit, $18
• Asutra Natural Sleep Mask Set, $20
• Tile Mate, $18 (was $25)
• Sharper Image Heated Neck and Shoulder Massager, $22 (was $25)
• Threshold Set of Two 4.5-Ounce Woodwick Amber Glass Candles, $10 
• A New Day Rhinestone Cloud Claw Hair Clip, $5
• Olive & June The Poppy Manicure Tool, $16
• Dr Teal’s Lavender Regimen Four-Piece Bath and Body Gift Set, $10 
• Cards Against Humanity: Everything Box Expansion for the Game, $20 
• Opalhouse Wine Tumbler, $5
• A New Day Gold Thick Hoop Earrings, $10 
• Burt’s Bees Hand Cream Trio Gift Set, $16
• E.l.f. Embellished Holiday Brush Gift Set, $20
• Olive & June Santa Baby Mani Nail Polish Gift Set, $14
• Clinique Find Your Happy Fragrance Gift Set, $13
• ColourPop Hugs & Kisses Lippie Stix Lip Makeup Trio Gift Set, $18
• Brightroom Bamboo Accessory Box With Acrylic Lid, $22
• Wondershop Holiday Merry & Bright Scuff Slippers, $20
• Good.Clean.Goop The Good Clean Daily Essentials Kit, $25
• Origins Gift to Treat Three-Piece Set, $20
• Kitsch Satin Pillowcase Scrunchie Hair Styling Gift Set, $20
• Open Story Two-Piece Neck Pillow & Sleep Mask Set, $15
• Fenty Snackz by Fenty Beauty by Rihanna Mini Stunna Lip Paint, $18

Sharper Image Heated Neck and Shoulder Massager

A lot of people spend the majority of their day either sitting at their desk or looking down at their phone, which means shoulder tension and neck pain is unfortunately universal. That also means everyone in the group will (or, at least should) be eyeing this heated neck and shoulder massager to help relieve the discomfort. While it’s currently 15 percent off, consider grabbing one for the exchange and another for yourself. 

Simple Modern 24-Ounce Stainless Steel Classic Tumbler

Simple Modern’s double-walled, vacuum-insulated tumblers rival other top brands with their ability to keep drinks hot or cold for hours. Plus, the straw lid makes for easy sipping while still being spill-proof. It comes in five colors, so you can pick a classic color that anyone would like, or you can pick your favorite color if you plan to steal it back—I won’t tell. 

Kitsch Satin Pillowcase Scrunchie Hair Styling Gift Set

Hair care products are a crowd-pleaser, and this satin pillowcase is something everyone should have to maintain healthy locks. In addition to a blush pillowcase in a standard size, the set includes three satin scrunchies in different neutral colors. This set can help reduce hair breakage, wrinkles, and breakouts, which is a gift that keeps on giving.

Keep scrolling for more white elephant gift ideas, including a two-piece necklace stack and a relaxing bath set, or take a look at Target’s gifting station for more inspiration this holiday season. 

A New Day 14K Gold Plated Duo Herringbone Chain Necklace Set

Dr Teal's Lavender Regimen Four-Piece Bath and Body Gift Set

Wondershop Holiday Merry & Bright Scuff Slippers