The Best Hand Saws, Tested
Hello, my friend, hello again; today we come together to talk about The Best Hand Saws, Tested and hope the blog can help you.
These quality hand saws will help you make the cuts your power saws can’t.
Walk the aisles of a home improvement store and it seems that every project requires power tools—compound miter saws, circular saws, jigsaws, reciprocating saws, and more.They make hand saws seem like relics from the past. Though it might seem like there’s a power saw for every cutting need, the fact is a hand saw for wood is still a vital tool. Sometimes, only the best hand saw can get the job done.
Using a hand saw obviously means there’s no need for electricity or batteries. These tools are lightweight, portable, easy to use, and often the best choice for specific tasks. Need a clean finished cut on a 6×6 timber? Trimming a few small tree limbs? A hand saw is almost always the best choice.
We tested eight highly rated hand saws from the most reputable tool brands. Whether you need a tool that can cut lumber, PVC pipe, metal, or branches, this guide can help. Read on to learn about the criteria we used to choose these saws, how they performed in testing, and why we think they are some of the best hand saws around.
- BEST OVERALL: DeWalt DWHT20544 15-Inch Hand Saw
- BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK: Craftsman CMHT20880 15-Inch General Purpose Hand Saw
- UPGRADE PICK: Spear & Jackson 24-Inch x 7 pts Skew Back Saw
- BEST FOR METAL: Lenox HT50 High Tension Hacksaw
- BEST FOR DRYWALL: DeWalt DWHT20540 Jab Saw
- BEST FOR PRECISION CUTS: Irwin 6½-Inch ProTouch Coping Saw
- BEST FOR WOODWORKING: Suizan 7-Inch Japanese Ryoba Pull Saw
- BEST FOR CAMPING: Silky Gomboy 240 Folding Saw
How We Tested the Best Hand Saws
We researched the most sought-after hand saws in their respective categories and discovered that the best models are determined by type, size, tooth count, and suitability for cutting different materials. Our picks included panel saws for general carpentry, along with hacksaw, jab, coping, dovetail, and pruning saws for more specialized tasks. Our selections run the gamut from 8 to 24 teeth per inch (TPI) for fast, aggressive cutting or fine finish work.
After unpacking and recording each saw’s size, weight, and TPI, we got busy, setting up “real-world” testing scenarios for each saw according to the tool’s design and intended use. Then we recorded our observations on a scoring rubric before awarding the “Best For…” awards used here.
We used the panel saws to cut 2×4 lumber across the grain and at a 45-degree angle and ripped 1×6 boards parallel to the grain. To test the hacksaw, we cut a steel pipe and a T-post clamped in a vice, then assembled a PVC pipe through a piece of plywood to simulate a flush cut. We mounted a square of drywall between 2×4 boards and drew cutout guide lines to test the jab saw.
We mitered sections of crown molding and baseboard trim at 45-degree angles and scribed the profiles at the ends in order to simulate fitting inside corners with the coping saw. To test the Japanese pull saw, we performed a series of crosscuts, 45-degree cuts, and rip cuts in several thicknesses of hardwood and softwood 1×4 boards. Finally, we tested the pruning saw by cutting through live branches and dead and dried limbs ranging from 2 to 4 inches in diameter.
Our Top Picks
Find out more about each of the saws we tested in the individual product reviews ahead. We discuss the tool characteristics, overall quality, and our personal observations from testing. One of these tools may be the best hand saw for your next project.
Best Overall
DeWalt DWHT20544 15-Inch Hand Saw
Photo: acehardware.com
DeWalt has built a strong reputation for quality tools at a fair price. This 15-inch panel saw makes a great choice for general carpentry projects including construction, fine woodworking, and repairs and maintenance. It features triple-ground induction-hardened teeth that enable the wood saw to cut up to 50 percent faster and stay sharp longer than other hand saws with traditional cross-ground teeth. A tough coating protects the high-speed steel blade from corrosion while reducing friction for easier, more efficient cutting strokes.
This 15-inch DeWalt hand saw has eight teeth per inch and is designed to cut on both the push stroke and pull stroke for rapid material removal. The blade attaches securely to the aluminum handle with three screws, and a cushioned synthetic grip increases user comfort. The handle features an integrated 45-degree and 90-degree angle guide. The handsaw weighs 16 ounces.
Based on average stroke count, the DeWalt saw did indeed cut faster than the other panel saws in our test group. It was comfortable to work with, moved smoothly through the wood, and worked well at different angles. It tracked well, easily making nice square cuts, and left fairly clean edges with just a few rough spots. We liked the compact size, although it bears mentioning that the shorter blade exposes each tooth to more wear and tear per cut compared to traditional 24-inch and 26-inch blades. Still, with the quality of the materials used to make this saw, we anticipate a good, long working life under typical working conditions.
Product Specs
- Type: Panel saw
- Number of teeth: 8 TPI
- Length: 15 inches
Pros
- Hardened-steel triple-ground teeth cut faster than conventional cross-ground teeth
- Smooth, tough blade coating resists binding and sap buildup
- Blade alignment and cushioned grip make the saw comfortable to use
- Compact size allows for portability and ease of use in close quarters
Cons
- Somewhat heavier than the similarly sized Craftsman hand saw we tested
Get the DeWalt 15-inch hand saw at Ace Hardware, The Home Depot, or Acme Tools.
Best Bang for the Buck
Craftsman CMHT20880 15-Inch General Purpose Hand Saw
Photo: lowes.com
One advantage of hand saws is that they aren’t as costly as electric hand saws, and this 15-inch Craftsman tool is one of the most inexpensive models available. Yet it doesn’t compromise efficiency for price. It features an 8 TPI tooth configuration with triple-ground teeth that cut deeper on the downstroke and milder on the backstroke for fast, smooth material removal. With its induction-hardened teeth, the carbon steel blade will stay sharp for a long time.
For added control, this saw boasts a beefy handle, giving users something substantial to hold, as well as a rubberized grip for greater comfort when sawing thicker boards. The handle also features built-in 90- and 45-degree angles for drawing clean and precise cut lines with the dull side of the blade. This lightweight hand saw weighs just 11 ounces.
We were impressed by the Craftsman hand saw’s fast and accurate cutting ability. In brand-new condition, it cut nearly as fast as the DeWalt saw, both on the single-stroke test and in the average strokes-per-cut test. However, the blade steel is a notch lower in quality, so we would expect it to dull somewhat sooner than our Best Overall pick; it’s also more susceptible to rust if left exposed to the elements. Occasional users who store the saw clean and dry may never experience a dull blade.
The saw moved well, even through deep cuts in thicker wood, and left fairly clean edges. The handle felt comfortable in hand and aligned well with the blade for efficient work. We noted that the synthetic handle seemed to be molded directly to the blade, so it should remain nice and tight for a long time. Overall, this saw presented an excellent price-to-quality value.
Product Specs
- Type: Panel saw
- Number of teeth: 8 TPI
- Length: 15 inches
Pros
- Triple-ground tooth configuration cuts quickly and provides less binding
- Induction-hardened teeth resist dulling and damage from nails or hard woods
- Sturdy, lightweight handle with a nonslip grip provides better control
Cons
- Not suitable for use on plastic, concrete, drywall, or metal
Get the Craftsman hand saw at Lowe’s or MSC.
Upgrade Pick
Spear & Jackson 24-Inch x 7 pts Skew Back Saw
Photo: amazon.com
Classic designs remain relevant when it comes to high-quality hand tools. This panel saw from Spear & Jackson incorporates traditional materials and craftsmanship for outstanding versatility in the workshop or on the jobsite. The 24-inch blade with its lightweight skew-back design offers a longer, more efficient saw stroke than shorter saws as well as excellent balance. The classic triple-riveted wooden handle offers a secure, comfortable grip.
This is the only back saw we tested that features resharpenable cross-ground teeth and a carbon-steel blade. Carbon steel is known for good edge retention and how easily it takes on a keen edge when sharpening. Favorable tooth geometry and 7 TPI make this saw a good choice for both rip sawing and crosscutting rough-sawn lumber. The saw weighs 1 pound 6 ounces.
We liked the long blade on the Spear & Jackson panel saw. The added length was especially helpful in reducing fatigue while cutting wider and thicker boards. Although we did not make enough cuts to dull the blade (that may have taken a few days’ work), we would expect this saw to stay sharp longer than the shorter models simply because a longer blade and more saw teeth means less wear per tooth.
On the other hand, this saw cut marginally slower than the DeWalt when we calculated the average strokes per cut and adjusted for the difference in blade length. But this saw outshined the other panel saws in the rip saw test, so it makes the best choice for versatility as well as total working life for those willin
Product Specs
- Type: Panel saw
- Number of teeth: 7 TPI
- Length: 24 inches
Pros
- Longer blade for more efficient cutting strokes and less user fatigue
- Traditional skew-back design improves the tool’s balance and reduces drag
- Cross-ground teeth can be resharpened to extend the saw’s working life
- Suitable for crosscutting or rip cutting all kinds of wood as well as PVC
Cons
- Wood handle is more susceptible to cracks and damage than some synthetic materials
- Larger size is less suitable for portability or tool box storage
Get the Spear & Jackson hand saw at Amazon.
Best For Metal
Lenox HT50 High Tension Hacksaw
Photo: amazon.com
When it comes to effectively cutting metal, a high-tension blade is crucial to ensure a straight cut. But how much tension is enough? This hacksaw from Lenox creates blade tension up to 50,000 pounds per square inch (PSI) to enable making a straight cut through even the toughest materials. The comfortable rubber grip gives the user ample control of this small saw.
The saw offers plenty of cool features, including a convenient storage cavity for up to five blades and a bracket for a second blade that turns the tool into a jab saw. The saw comes with a 12-inch 24-TPI bimetal hacksaw blade, and it weighs in at 1 pound 9 ounces.
We tested the Lenox HT50 on tubular steel pipe, a steel T-post, and for flush cutting 4-inch PVC pipe. In each case, the high tensile strength of the blade bracket prevented binding and twisting, even when the blade became pinched in the workpiece near the end of a cut. It cut quickly and accurately every time.
Another nice feature was the option to mount the blade either straight or at a 45-degree angle. The angled blade mounts made it much easier to flush cut the PVC pipe down to the plywood surface from which it extended, without marring the wood.
The saw did not come with a jab saw blade, so we tested that feature with a 6-inch reciprocating saw blade that we had in our shop. It worked, but maneuvering the heavy saw body behind the smallish blade felt a bit cumbersome.
Product Specs
- Type: Hacksaw
- Number of teeth: 24 TPI
- Length: 12 inches
Pros
- High-tension blade makes cleaner, more accurate cuts with less twisting
- Rubber gripped handle resists slipping and improves user comfort
- Storage cavity for up to 5 blades saves time and tool box space
- Deep throat spacious enough to cut pipes up to 4 inches in diameter
Cons
- Heavier and bulkier than other hacksaws; may increase user fatigue with extended use
Get the Lenox hand saw at Amazon, Ace Hardware, or Acme Tools.
Best For Drywall
DeWalt DWHT20540 Jab Saw
Photo: amazon.com
Comfort is paramount in quality handheld tools, especially for dirty jobs like hacking through drywall. Without a motor, the sawyer’s arm does all the work—so one reason why we like this DeWalt jab saw is its molded rubberized grip, which provides a firm, solid hold.
Thanks to aggressive tooth geometry at 8 TPI, this saw makes quick work out of drywall cutting jobs. It speeds through projects with less effort and can cut through other building materials, too, including plastic. And, with its induction-hardened teeth, the blade should stay sharp through many projects. The saw blade measures 6.5 inches long, and the tool’s total weight is just 4.5 ounces.
When we tested the DeWalt jab saw, several helpful features stood out. The tip of the saw was not as fine as some others we’ve used, but the added metal and sharpness made for a strong configuration that penetrated ½-inch drywall easily. A flat spot at the rear of the handle offered a convenient spot to strike for added force. The long triple-ground saw teeth cut into the drywall cleanly without tearing the paper at the edges of the cut. The cushioned handle was comfortable to grip and made it easy to control the blade for straight or curved cutting.
Our only criticism, which is oddly common among this kind of saw, is that it does not come with a blade cover. The sharp point and sharp teeth can wreak havoc on a soft-sided tool bag and risk injuring anyone caught unaware. It’s a top-notch tool when needed, but be sure to store and transport with caution.
Product Specs
- Type: Jab saw
- Number of teeth: 8 TPI
- Length: 6 inches
Pros
- Molded rubberized handle for a comfortable grip and good control
- Suitable for cutting drywall, plastic, and other thin wood materials
- Triple-ground induction-hardened teeth for faster cutting and better wear resistance
Cons
- Purpose-built for a narrow range of cutting tasks; low versatility
Get the DeWalt jab hand saw at Ace Hardwareor The Home Depot.