The Best Exterior Wood Stains of 2024, Tested
Hello, my friend, hello again; today we come together to talk about The Best Exterior Wood Stains of 2024, Tested and hope the blog can help you.
Add an attractive protective finish to the wood surfaces around your home with these top exterior wood stains.
Outdoor wood furniture and structures look great when they’re brand new; however, using exterior wood stains will protect them from the effects of the sun, rain, snow, and wind for years to come. We tested 10 exterior wood stains, applying them to various wood species and subjecting them to foot traffic and wet weather to uncover the top performers.
The best exterior wood stains will protect your wood structures, siding, or furniture while also achieving your ideal color and transparency. Our favorite product is the Defy Extreme Semi-Transparent Wood Stain, which produces beautiful rich colors, is easy to apply, and provides plenty of protection from the elements. Keep reading to discover the qualities you’ll want to consider when shopping for the best exterior wood stains and learn about our top recommendations.
- BEST OVERALL: Defy Extreme Semi-Transparent Wood Stain
↓ Jump to Review - RUNNER-UP: Olympic Maximum Wood Stain & Sealant
↓ Jump to Review - BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK: Storm System Semi-Transparent Stain & Sealer
↓ Jump to Review - BEST FOR DECKS: Ready Seal Wood Stain and Sealer
↓ Jump to Review - BEST EASY-TO-APPLY: SaverSystems #1 Deck Premium Wood Stain
↓ Jump to Review - BEST LOW-VOC: Vermont Natural Coatings PolyWhey Exterior Stain
↓ Jump to Review - BEST WATER-RESISTANT: Thompson’s WaterSeal Transparent Wood Sealer
↓ Jump to Review - BEST COVERAGE: Behr Premium Waterproofing Stain & Sealer
↓ Jump to Review
How We Tested the Best Exterior Wood Stains
Our main focus when testing the best exterior wood stains was to determine how well they beautified natural wood while also protecting it from moisture and wear and tear. We also considered ease of application and cost.
We tested each exterior stain on three types of wood: pine lumber, premium-grade pine for finish woodworking, and poplar. After allowing each stain to dry for the amount of time directed by the manufacturer, we tested the durability by walking over and dragging patio furniture across each wood sample. We also sprayed each sample with water to determine which wood stains repelled or absorbed the moisture.
Finally, we scored each stain based on a rubric that included points for ease of application, appearance, durability, and value. Once testing was complete, we used these scores to rank the tested products.
| Testing Stats | |
| Products tested | 10 |
| Time spent testing | 40 hours |
| Tests performed | 5 |
| Price range | $33 to $57 per gallon |
Our Top Picks
With a bit of background on the subject, selecting outdoor stains for wood doesn’t have to be complicated. Our top picks include some of the best products on the market to make it even easier. Shoppers will want to keep in mind factors like intended use, stain type, and preferred transparency and color when comparing these options to choose the best exterior wood stains for any application.
Best Overall
Defy Extreme Semi-Transparent Wood Stain
Photo: Amazon
Our Ratings: Application 5/5; Appearance 5/5; Durability 4.5/5; Value 4/5
Product Specs
- Type: Water-based with acrylic resin
- Transparency: Semitransparent
- Color(s): 6 wood tones
- Drying time: 2 to 6 hours (24 hours to fully cure)
What We Like
- Thicker consistency reduces drips and runs
- Rich semitransparent finish accentuates wood grain
- Durable formula resists scuffs and beads water
What We Don’t Like
- Only offers 6 color options
Of all the stains we tested, Defy Extreme semitransparent wood stain delivered the most well-rounded performance. This stain has a slightly thicker consistency than other semitransparent stains we tested, which made it easier to apply without having to worry about runs or drips. And since it dried quickly, we were able to apply a second coat after just a few hours. Defy Extreme produced a deep, beautiful finish that accentuated the natural grains in all three types of wood we tested it on with no visible brushstrokes or streaks.
We also loved the durability of this wood stain. True to the name, Defy Extreme resisted our attempts to mark it up with a pair of shoes and heavy metal patio furniture. It also was among the best against moisture, with water beading up on the wood surface during our spray test. This water-based stain cleans up easily with soap and water, and it contains the same zinc found in sunscreen to reflect the sun’s harmful rays before they can damage the wood.
Defy Extreme is only available in six deck stain colors—cedar tone, natural pine, light walnut, butternut, redwood, and gray—which can make it a challenge to match your home’s color scheme. However, given its superior performance and ease of use, Defy Extreme is our top pick for the best all-around exterior wood stain if the limited color options suit your needs.
Get the Defy exterior wood stain at Amazon.
Runner-Up
Olympic Maximum Wood Stain & Sealant
Photo: Amazon
Our Ratings: Application 3.7/5; Appearance 5/5; Durability 4.5/5; Value 4.5/5
Product Specs
- Type: Oil-based
- Transparency: Semitransparent
- Color(s): Over 100 wood tones
- Drying time: Around 24 hours (varies with temperature and humidity)
What We Like
- Apply in wet or dry conditions
- Rain ready in 8 hours
- Provides a mold- and mildew-resistant coating
- Features scuff-guard technology
- Produces a beautiful finish with no streaking
What We Don’t Like
- Extended drying time of 24 hours
Olympic yielded some of the best results of any of the stains we tested. With a thicker consistency similar to a paint or solid deck stain, Olympic Maximum wood stain and sealant was easy to apply and limited the amount of runs or drips. It also produced a rich, beautiful finish free of streaks or brushstrokes. While our Canyon Brown test color was transparent, it covered more like a semitransparent stain, leaving the wood grain very visible.
This hardy stain deflected our best efforts to mar the finish, a testament to its scuff-guard technology. It also handled our spray test well with water beading up on the surface. Since this formula features ultraviolet (UV)-blocking technology, it’s also fade-resistant. Olympic Maximum is oil-based, so while it has a longer dry time of around 24 hours, surfaces are rain ready in just 8 hours. It’s available in 10 wood-tone colors that can be tinted to create over 100 tones.
Olympic Maximum wood stain and sealant certainly requires more work and patience during the application process, but the beautiful and durable finish makes it worth the additional effort.
Get the Olympic exterior wood stain at Amazon, Tractor Supply Co., or The Home Depot.
Best Bang for the Buck
Storm System Semi-Transparent Stain & Sealer
Photo: Amazon
Our Ratings: Application 3/5; Appearance 4/5; Durability 3.5/5; Value 5/5
Product Specs
- Type: Oil-based
- Transparency: Semitransparent
- Color(s): 6 wood tones
- Drying time: 24 hours
What We Like
- Excellent coverage at an affordable price
- Creates a rich, beautiful finish
- Applies smoothly and produces an even coating
What We Don’t Like
- Extended drying time of 24 hours
- Oil-based formula makes for cumbersome mixing
- Doesn’t resist water as well as other stains
When it comes to getting as much value from a gallon of stain as possible, this semitransparent stain and sealer from Storm System fits the bill. The budget-friendly price tag aside, 1 gallon of this stain can cover up to 175 square feet of smooth-surface deck space, fencing, or siding—as well as several pieces of outdoor furniture—with multiple coats.
Storm System stain is an oil-based formula, which made applying it during our testing more of a chore. We found ourselves spending an inordinate amount of time stirring the stain to ensure all the pigment that had settled to the bottom of the can mixed with the binder and finishing agent. Once we finally had it mixed to our satisfaction, the stain applied well and created a beautiful, even coat over all three of our wood types. Due to the oil-based formula, Storm System stain has a long dry time of 24 hours between coats, which extended our application time significantly over the water-based stains we tested.
While this stain passed our scuff tests, we were disappointed with its water resistance. When we sprayed our wood samples, water did not bead off the wood as we would expect with an oil-based stain, raising concerns about its long-term ability to resist the elements. That said, given the coverage, affordable price, and beautiful finish, this is a good option for shoppers looking for a budget-priced stain who don’t mind the hassle of using an oil-based formula.
Get the Storm System exterior wood stain at Amazon.
Best for Decks
Ready Seal Wood Stain and Sealer
Photo: Amazon
Our Ratings: Application 4/5; Appearance 5/5; Durability 4/5; Value 3.5/5
Product Specs
- Type: Oil-based
- Transparency: Semitransparent
- Color(s): 8 wood tones
- Drying time: 48 to 72 hours (depending on weather conditions)
What We Like
- Easy to apply without streaks or inconsistencies
- Durable oil-based formula resists scuffs and water
- Beautiful rich finish accentuates natural wood grains
What We Don’t Like
- Extended drying time of at least 48 hours
- Costs nearly double of some other outdoor wood stains
Between lap marks and brushstrokes, staining a large deck can be a hassle. With Ready Seal semitransparent stain and sealer, that’s not an issue thanks to its “Goof Proof” formula designed to easily attain a high-quality, streak-free finish. And while “Goof Proof” may sound gimmicky, this wood stain truly works. We applied Ready Seal stain with a basic brush and had no problem achieving an even coating, even without using back brushing or other special brush techniques.
The finished results were impressive. This exterior stain produces beautiful colors while still allowing enough grain to show through to preserve the wood’s natural look. The oil-based formula does require a degree of patience, as it can take at least 48 hours to fully dry. However, Ready Seal stain creates a durable shell once dry. During our testing, it resisted our best efforts to scuff the wood samples, and water beaded up nicely on the surface.
While the results are worth the wait, time isn’t the only thing this stain will cost you. Ready Seal wood stain is pricey at nearly twice the cost of some other stains we tested. Still, if you’re seeking superior performance and would like to extend the time until your next resealing effort, then it may be worth the extra effort and investment.
Best Easy-to-Apply
SaverSystems #1 Deck Premium Wood Stain
Photo: Amazon
Our Ratings: Application 5/5; Appearance 5/5; Durability 3.5/5; Value 4.5/5
Product Specs
- Type: Water-based
- Transparency: Semitransparent
- Color(s): 4 wood tones
- Drying time: 24 hours
What We Like
- Produces rich, beautiful colors
- Forgiving formula ensures quality results
- One of the more affordably priced wood stains
What We Don’t Like
- Less water resistance than other stains
- May require reapplication more often than other stains
Protecting exterior wood surfaces like decks, siding, furniture, and fences doesn’t get much easier than with SaverSystems #1 Deck Premium semitransparent wood stain. Of all the stains we tested, few applied as easily as this option. It produced an even coat with no inconsistencies or brushstrokes on any of our three wood types. And since we could apply the second coat in just 30 minutes, we were able to work quickly. Savers Systems stain is also water-based and uses a formula that’s low in volatile organic compounds (VOCs), so it had a very mild odor and was easy to clean up.
While we liked the ease of application and cleanup, we did have some concerns about durability. This stain passed our scuff test with flying colors, but water didn’t bead up on the surface during our spray test as well as it did with other stains we tested—an indication that this stain may not last as long as other products. Additionally, SaverSystems wood stain only comes in four color options, which can be problematic if you’re trying to coordinate your deck, fence, or outdoor furniture with your house color.
One gallon of this wood stain will cover up to 150 square feet with two coats, which is about average. For shoppers looking for an easy-to-apply deck stain who don’t mind more frequent reapplication, SaverSystems stain is a great option.
Get the SaverSystems exterior wood stain at Amazon.
Best Low-VOC
Vermont Natural Coatings PolyWhey Exterior Stain
Photo: Amazon
Our Ratings: Application 3.4/5; Appearance 4/5; Durability 4/5; Value 3/5
Product Specs
- Type: Water-based
- Transparency: Semitransparent
- Color(s): 14
- Drying time: 48 hours (cure)
What We Like
- Leaves an attractive finish after several coats
- Provides ample protection from scuffs and water
- Low-VOC formula that uses a renewable resource as a binder