The 14 Best Comfortable Heels of 2024, Tested and Reviewed
Whether you’re commuting to the office or heading to a late-night soiree, a good pair of heels can elevate any outfit. And while you’ve likely heard the expression “beauty is pain,” we’re here to prove it doesn’t have to be. The best heels look good and feel better, leaving you confident and comfortable.
We tested 28 pairs of heels at home, evaluating them based on fit, comfort, support, quality, and value. For expert tips on how to shop for the best comfortable heels, we consulted Dr. Lori Weisenfeld, DPM, New York City sports podiatrist, and personal stylist Yael Steren. Read on for our favorite picks, including stilettos, pumps, wedges, and more.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/DREAM-PAIRS-Womens-Chunk-Low-Heel-Pump-Sandals-eaaface4df364c6fa29983f644d8e28d.jpg)
-
These versatile heels are shockingly comfortable, requiring no break-in period.
-
The toe strap may hurt your feet if worn for longer periods.
Timeless and comfortable, the Dream Pairs Pump Sandals earned our title of best comfortable heels. When we first began testing them, they were comfortable right off the bat. They fit true to size and required no painful break-in period. We found the 3-inch heel to be the ideal height, and the arch support felt perfect. The straps were similarly comfortable, though they did get a bit uncomfortable on our toes when we wore them for longer periods of time.
Available in 30 colors—including simple nude hues and more adventurous glitter options—these heels will work with pretty much any outfit. Despite being on the dressier side, we were able to wear them with basic jeans and formal dresses alike. After six months of use, the heels are still exceeding our expectations: They have maintained their high quality with no visible signs of wear. Given their impressive durability and classic design, we think these heels are here to stay.
Heel Height: 3 inches | Size Range: 5–12 | Material: 100% suede | Outsole: Rubber
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/rsp-comfortable-heels-test-dream-pairs-womens-chunk-low-pump-sandals-osp-beth-martinson-03-a892a7df0a844e2c987ca2748aa6599d.jpeg)
Wade Review / Beth Martinson
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/everlane-the-italian-leather-day-heel-667ad57f22e6400382a3de194222d011.jpg)
-
The leather is high quality, and the sturdy, low heel makes them suitable for daily wear.
-
They don’t offer much arch support.
While some heels are for special occasions, others, like the Everlane Day Heel, are comfortable and casual enough for everyday use. When we first slipped them on, we knew right away that these would be some of the most comfortable ones we tested. Since they’re low to the ground—only measuring 2 inches in height—they felt sturdy on our ankles. We also appreciate the elastic on the back, which gave our feet some room to move and breathe.
Crafted from Italian leather, these heels scream high quality. They come in six rich colors, along with the option of a “narrow” or “comfort” fit. It’s worth noting that these heels don’t offer much arch support, and our foot did get a bit tired after hours of wearing them. Despite this, we found them to be well made, and they didn’t feel flimsy at all. Even after six months of use, the leather has held up perfectly. Thanks to their durability and manageable height, these make a great beginner pair for those just starting to wear heels.
Heel Height: 2 inches | Size Range: 5–11 | Materials: Leather | Outsole: Leather
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/rsp-comfortable-heels-test-everlane-italian-leather-day-jessica-vadillo-05-3e7a5f3b864643439ad454c96522977e.jpeg)