The Best Soft Mattress Toppers To Give Your Bed A Plush Makeover

Type: Memory foam | Height: 3 inches | Trial period: No | Warranty: 10 years

Tempur-Pedic is known for its proprietary memory foam, and this mattress topper succeeds by achieving the right balance of support and comfort. The material is more durable than memory foam and instantly responds to your shape and temperature. Featuring 3 inches of luxury foam, this topper is described as “extra-soft,” making it ideal for side sleepers or anyone seeking pressure relief for their shoulders and hips. 

The company thoughtfully includes corner straps that keep the topper from slipping as well as a high-stretch cover that’s not only breathable but also removable and washable. Plus, the zip-off cover encompasses the entire topper, making it resistant to dust mites and allergens. If you sleep hot, you have the option of upgrading the topper with cooling features.

Pros:

• Removable and washable cover
• Non-slip corner straps

Cons:

• Cooling features available at an additional cost
• Some reviews say that it’s too soft

What the reviews say: According to one one 5-star reviewer, “This foam topper is extra soft, which helps my back pain. It also stays put since it has 4 straps.” Another consumer appreciates the design by saying: “We love this mattress topper; it just feels like it’s giving you a hug.”

Type: Memory foam | Height: 2, 3 or 4 inches | Trial period: 30-day return | Warranty: 3 years

Quality sleep is attainable on any budget, as evidenced by this affordable memory foam topper with over 60,000 reviews. The four-inch option adds a thick, plush feel to any firm or worn-out mattress. While it’s available in several thickness options, the thicker models are ideal if you’re searching for ultimate softness. 

Memory foam typically retains heat, but this topper combats that by infusing it with gel material to capture and dissipate the heat. Plus, the foam is designed with additional ventilation to improve airflow. This plush memory foam eliminates pressure points by distributing weight evenly and contouring to every curve. The end result is spine alignment and waking up without back pain. It’s also available in various sizes, from twin to California king.

Pros:

• Cooling gel
• Available in several thicknesses and sizes

Cons:

• No cover
• The company recommends letting it sit for 48 hours to shed the new foam smell

What the reviews say: With over 60,000 reviews, many tout the quality and comfort of this topper. “My body feels so soothingly cradled,” says a customer. “I’m not tossing and turning constantly trying to get comfortable. It’s just pure bliss. This may sound strange, but it feels like a hug. It does. It really does. Like a hug from the Pillsbury Dough Boy.”

Type: Memory foam | Height: 3 inches | Trial period: No | Warranty: 5 years

Each groove and peak on this mattress topper is strategically placed to offer five targeted comfort zones that support the head, shoulders, torso, legs and feet. This focused support contours to the body and relieves pressure based on weight distribution, making it comfortable for everyone, especially side sleepers. Additionally, the raised zones promote airflow to keep you cool.

Instead of a cover that only encases the topper, this product comes with a deep-pocket mattress protector that not only keeps the topper from shifting while you sleep but also protects your investment. This moisture-wicking cover is designed with a cooling Ghost Ice fabric for additional relief. It’s also water-resistant and keeps out dust mites. As a bonus, it’s made in the USA with CertiPUR-US certified memory foam and is free of harmful chemicals.

Pros:

• Included cooling and water-resistant mattress protector
• CertiPUR-US certified and made in the USA

Cons:

• No trial period
• Could have a smell

What the reviews say: “I love the different zones,” raves one reviewer. “What pleasantly surprised me was the zone for the feet and legs. My heels sink in and feel cradled.” Another loves the feel, saying, “It’s very comfortable and soft. I can sleep on my side and not feel any pain in my hip. I like the cooling feeling of the cover.”

Type: Memory foam | Height: 2.5 inches | Trial period: 101 nights | Warranty: Lifetime

Buying any sleep product online can be stressful. Fortunately, Puffy eliminates the stress with a risk-free trial for 101 nights as well as a lifetime warranty. The 2.5 inches of premium memory foam is designed to contour your body as you sleep and can even benefit those with back pain. It’s described as “soft” and is available in various sizes, including twin XL and California king.

It’s designed with a cover featuring deep elastic pockets (like a sheet) and will fit a mattress up to 15 inches thick. What’s more, this topper also features a grippy layer to keep from moving around at night. This cover is hypoallergenic and designed to keep out dust mites. Since it’s made of bamboo viscose and polyester, it integrates airflow to keep you feeling cool and comfortable. Plus, it’s also removable and washable for easy cleaning and hygienic purposes.

Pros:

• 101-night risk-free trial and lifetime warranty
• Washable cover that keeps topper from sliding

Cons:

• Not ideal for those who dislike the “sink-in” feeling
• Heavy people may find it too soft 

What the reviews say: “The soft mattress topper was a great balance of support and softness,” begins one testimonial. “You do not sink straight through to the mattress below, and it adds a layer of softness to our mattress. Our mattress provided good support but did not have the plushness we wanted. [The Puffy mattress topper] was a great option to get a bed that feels new without having to buy an entirely new mattress.”

Type: Down | Height: 3 inches | Trial period: 60 days | Warranty: 3 years

Down is an excellent alternative if you want to soften up your sleeping surface but don’t appreciate the sinking feeling you can sometimes encounter with memory foam. This topper is made in the USA with 3 inches of premium European white down and feather fill that the brand claims “makes you feel like you’re sinking into a marshmallow-stuffed cloud each night.” This cloud-like feeling is also due to the topper’s dual-chamber design—the top is filled with a combination of 85% down and 15% down and feather fibers, while the bottom chamber is filled entirely with feather fill.

To combat down’s tendency to clump, this topper is designed with three-dimensional baffle box stitching that keeps the fill evenly distributed. The shell is made of sateen cotton, so it feels soothing to the touch. This topper is also reinforced with double-stitched piping seams, so you shouldn’t see pesky feathers poking out the sides.

Pros:

• Decent trial and warranty
• Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified and made in the USA

Cons:

• Dry clean only
• No straps to secure it to the mattress

What the reviews say: One shopper says, “No words for how amazing this topper is. It literally feels like you are sleeping on a cloud. I have never had a better night’s sleep in my life.”

Type: Hybrid | Height: 5 inches | Trial period: 100 nights | Warranty: 5 years

While this mattress topper is made primarily of memory foam, it’s not a single piece of foam that you sink into, but rather cross-cut foam blended with microfiber. It’s then divided into dozens of plush memory foam pockets separated with a baffle box construction. This design ensures clump-free distribution and unrivaled loft—5 inches, to be exact. As the thickest topper on our list, the brand claims the extra inches provide the highest level of support for your pressure points. 

The virgin memory foam and soft microfiber outer cover are always free from harmful chemicals, given their CertiPUR-US and GREENGUARD Gold certifications. Another benefit of the cross-cut foam blend, when compared to a pad of memory foam, is that it’s much more breathable and promotes airflow to release excess body heat. Plus, it’s designed with straps on each corner to keep it secured to the mattress all night.

Pros:

• Generous trial and warranty
• Straps to hold it in place

Cons:

• 5-inch height may make your mattress too thick
• Spot clean only

What the reviews say: “This topper has eliminated tossing, turning and multiple waking up during the night, followed by soreness in the morning,” writes a repeat customer. “I wake up feeling refreshed. I linger in bed just because it is so cozy. At first, I was concerned that it would be too thick and soft. The filling is perfect and supportive, but not too soft and not hot. This is my fourth topper and the best.”

Type: Talalay latex | Height: 2 or 3 inches | Trial period: No | Warranty: 5 years

Latex is an excellent alternative to memory foam, especially if you want a soft surface without that sinking feeling. This topper is made from Talalay latex, which is 100% natural and GOLS certified organic—so you can be sure there are no chemicals, blends or synthetics. It’s also Oeko-Tex Standard 100 and GREENGUARD Gold certified. When compared to memory foam, Talalay latex is generally more breathable, and it’s also softer than Dunlop latex, making it the ideal choice for anyone looking for a responsive yet soft topper. 

Regardless of your sleeping preference, this organic latex topper is available in several thicknesses, comfort levels and sizes. So, you can choose the soft model for extra cushioning or a medium-soft option if you require a tad more support. As a natural latex product, it’s also hypoallergenic, odorless, anti-microbial and resistant to dust mites and mildew, making it perfect for anyone with allergies.

Pros:

• Flippable to elongate the life of mattress topper
• GOLS certified organic, Oeko-Tex Standard 100 and GREENGUARD Gold certified

Cons:

• No trial period
• No straps to keep it from slipping

What the reviews say: Overall, customers who have purchased this latex topper are very satisfied. One writes, “We both have experienced so much comfort from this topper. It’s like lying on a cloud! We purchased the softest ILD they make. It is never warm or hot. It remains cool all night. It’s easy to roll over when in bed, and have no trouble getting out of bed. We like it better than memory foam. This may be the best purchase we have ever made in over 40 years. No more body aches or stiffness upon waking. Our bed is an unbelievably soft, cushiony haven now.”