The Best Mattress Pads That Add A Comfy, Protective Layer To Your Bed

Material: Organic cotton | Pocket depth: 16 inches | Trial: 45-day return policy | Warranty: 1 year

Pros:

• Generous trial and warranty
• 100% certified GOTS organic cotton

Cons:

• Not entirely waterproof

For a versatile option that offers a little bit of everything, consider this Saatva mattress pad. It’s made with GOTS-certified organic cotton that extends down the sides, making it excellent at wicking away moisture. It’s been tested to ensure that it’s chemical-free and 100% organic. What’s more, the brand uses Fair Trade Certified factories that adhere to rigorous economic and responsibility standards. The diamond-quilted design isn’t extraordinarily thick, but it adds a slight softness while retaining its natural breathable properties for cooler nights. This mattress pad provides protection against general wear and tear and light stains, which can help keep your mattress like new. With an extra-wide elastic band, it stays in place all night on mattresses up to 16 inches tall.

What the reviews say: “I never cared for mattress pads before,” says a 5-star review. “They just seemed like a hassle and another thing to add when doing my bed. But I was wrong. This mattress pad is unlike anything I’ve tried in the past. It’s very plush yet doesn’t add bulk to my mattress. The elastic band is so secure, and the pockets are super deep, accommodating my thick mattress perfectly. I like knowing my mattress is protected by this plush layer. I think it’ll really add years to it.”

Material: Polyester microfiber | Pocket depth: 21 inches | Trial: 30-day return policy | Warranty: None

Pros:

• Budget-friendly
• Fits mattresses up to 21 inches deep

Cons:

• Not water resistant
• Some reviews note that it’s not very breathable

For an affordable way to spruce up an uncomfortable mattress, this Bedsure mattress pad is an excellent option. Since it has a 21-inch pocket depth, it fits nearly every mattress and setup, even if you have a four-inch mattress topper. This comfortable pad is constructed with three ergonomic zones—a soft wavy design at the top and bottom for relaxation and a honeycomb-shaped quilted design in the middle to disperse body pressure and evenly distribute support. Plus, it’s filled with a microfiber blend to add a plush feel. It’s important to note that this mattress pad isn’t water resistant, so doesn’t stop big spills from soaking through. However, it still works to protect your mattress from dirt, food stains and normal wear and tear. Plus, it is machine washable and available in all standard sizes from twin to California king.

What the reviews say: One customer writes, “We bought this to fit over a 3-inch mattress topper on a 13-inch king-size bed. The elastic easily secured to all four corners. The padding is so soft and provides another 1 inch of comfort. We washed it immediately upon receiving [it] and put [it] on the bed directly out of the dryer. It fits great, looks good and feels well-made. We can’t wait to sleep on it tonight. I am so happy about this purchase.”

Material: Tencel lyocell and mica nylon blend | Pocket depth: 18 inches | Trial: 7-day trial and 30-day return policy | Warranty: None

Pros:

• Fits deep mattresses
• Completely waterproof

Cons:

• No warranty
• Not available for twin-size beds

While some mattress pads are specifically cooling, this Sijo mattress pad actually regulates body temperature to cool you down when it’s hot and warm you up when it’s cold. This feature makes it perfect for year-round use, thanks to the brand’s patented blend of fibers that works to both absorb and distribute excess body heat. Plus, the fibers are also hypoallergenic and feel luxurious and soft. For protective properties, moisture-wicking membranes are embedded in the material, making this pad completely waterproof. It’s also soundless and doesn’t feel stiff like some waterproof covers. All products hold FSC and Oeko-Tex certifications, so you can be sure the materials are responsibly and sustainably harvested and align with eco-friendly values. This mattress pad is machine washable and suitable for the dryer on low heat.

What the reviews say: “I have been looking for different ways to help out with how warm I get at night,” notes a review. “It’s especially bad in summer, obviously, but it’s an all-year-round affair for this sweaty neuro-divergent gal. I also have two pets who sleep in bed with me. They both like to be touching me in some way, and they are tiny furnaces. Ever since I put this TempTune mattress pad on the bed, we’re all sleeping way more comfortably.”

Material: Polyester and nylon | Pocket depth: 15 inches | Trial: 100-night trial | Warranty: 10 years

Pros:

• Entirely waterproof
• Hypoallergenic and antimicrobial

Cons:

• Doesn’t add much cushion

Accidents are bound to happen if you sleep with pets or children or even like to snack in bed. This Sleep Number mattress pad is completely waterproof to protect your expensive investment and help extend the life of your mattress. The waterproof and stain-protective surface also extends down the sides for even more peace of mind. It holds a Standard 100 certification from Oeko-Tex, ensuring it’s free from harmful chemicals. The Total Protection Mattress Pad is hypoallergenic and antimicrobial to ensure it stays bacteria and odor-free. It’s also designed to let heat and humidity escape while preventing moisture from penetrating the surface, helping it stay cool to the touch. This pad is also suitable for adjustable beds.

What the reviews say: A pet owner writes, “We have three dogs, and this total protection pad really does give us peace of mind knowing that our mattress is completely protected. Their 100% guarantee is amazing, and we have been sleeping worry free ever since we purchased this. It’s easy to wash, easy to put on the mattress and [there are] no issues whatsoever with it!”

Material: Cotton sateen shell with microfiber fill | Pocket depth: 18 inches | Trial: 60-day return policy | Warranty: 3 years

Pros:

• Generous return policy and warranty
• Fits deep mattresses

Cons:

• Not entirely waterproof
• Some reviews note a crinkling noise when you move around

This down alternative mattress pad from Parachute is ideal for those who want the cloud-like softness of down without the high price tag. Since it’s made with 100% hypoallergenic microfiber fill, it’s also an excellent option for those with allergies. However, this filling still mimics the fluffiness and warmth you expect from natural down. The outer shell is 100% cotton and certified Oeko-Tex Standard 100. The mattress pad is stitched in a square design throughout to keep the fill evenly distributed, which reduces the risk of clumping. You can machine wash it on the delicate setting and tumble dry it on the low setting.

What the reviews say: “I have noticed a real difference in sleep using my new Down Alternative Mattress Pad,” says a five-star review. “It replaced an older pad I had previously. It has more loft than others, and I’m convinced [it] magically makes you toss and turn less. I find myself waking up in the same position I fell asleep in, which once was unusual. Definitely a happy purchase.”

Material: Bamboo-rayon blend and cotton | Pocket depth: 15 inches | Trial: 101 nights | Warranty: Lifetime

Pros:

• Generous amount of cushioning
• Hypoallergenic

Cons:

• Not waterproof

While most mattress pads are thin and don’t drastically change the feel of your mattress, this Puffy Mattress Pad adds two inches of cushioning to breathe life into an old mattress or soften up a firm one. In addition to being comfortable, the bamboo-rayon blend and cotton are also naturally breathable to help you sleep cooler at night. Plus, the material is also hypoallergenic, making it gentle on your skin and suitable for those with allergies. Since it’s machine washable and dryer suitable, keeping this mattress pad clean is practically effortless. For peace of mind, it’s also Oeko-Tex Standard 100 certified against up to 350 harmful chemicals. While it’s not waterproof, it can still shield and keep dirt off your mattress and extend its overall life.

What the reviews say: One customer notes the plush feel, saying, “[I] ordered this because my mattress (not a Puffy) was a bit too hard, and I was experiencing neck and shoulder pain. This pad was the perfect amount of softness. I have not had any pain in the morning since. My bed is now so comfortable.”

Material: Organic cotton | Pocket depth: 16 inches | Trial: 100 nights | Warranty: 1 year

Pros:

• Generous trial and warranty
• GOTS and Fair Trade certified

Cons:

• Not completely waterproof

In addition to being made with GOTS-certified organic cotton, this Birch Mattress Pad also holds a Fair Trade certificate, so you can be sure it’s made under ethical conditions. With three distinct layers that each provide a specific function, this mattress pad is soft, protective and moisture wicking. While it’s not entirely waterproof, the cotton sateen in the top layer is designed in a unique wave pattern that protects against absorption of spills. What’s more, the organic cotton is naturally breathable, promoting ventilation and airflow for a cool night of sleep. Another special feature is the elastic no-slip band, which adheres to the outside of the pad instead of the inside. It works by gripping the foundation or bed frame beneath your mattress to ensure it stays put all night.

What the reviews say: “[I] absolutely love this mattress pad,” says a five star review. “I bought it specifically because it had silicon on the ends that wrap under the mattress. It does not slip or make your sheets bunch up. And it’s organic cotton. [It is an] excellent mattress pad. [I] wish I bought it sooner.”

Material: Cotton and proprietary Outlast fabric |