The 10 Best Down-Alternative Comforters And Duvet Inserts To Keep Cozy
Having the right comforter on your bed can make or break your sleep, determining whether you sleep like a baby or fight the covers because you’re too hot or too cold. A down-alternative comforter can keep you at a comfortable temperature and mimics that light, fluffy feel of real down. It can also help reduce allergen build-up, and many are machine-washable for added convenience. Our pick for the best down-alternative comforter is the Brooklinen Down-Alternative Comforter, which is a standout option featuring a soft, sustainable construction with three weight choices to fit various needs.
The terms “comforter” and “duvet insert” technically describe two different products, however, in most instances they can be used interchangeably. The main difference is that duvet inserts have loops in the corners to attach with ties to the inside of a duvet cover, which protects it from stains and reduces the need to wash the duvet insert as often. Typically, comforters have been designed to be used on their own, so they don’t come with loops. But these days, many comforters are made with loops in the corners to work with a duvet cover. Below, find our top picks for the best down-alternative comforters for the coziest sleep.
-
Best Down-Alternative Comforter Overall: Brooklinen Down-Alternative Comforter (Full/Queen)
-
Best All-Season Down-Alternative Comforter: FluffCo Down-Alternative Comforter (Queen)
-
Warmest Down-Alternative Comforter: The Company Store Legends Luxury Luxe Loftaire Ultra Olympia Down-Alternative Comforter (Queen)
-
Best Value Down-Alternative Comforter: Puredown All-Seasons Dobby Square Down-Alternative Comforter (Full/Queen)
-
Best Midweight Down-Alternative Comforter: Sijo Clima Tech TempTune All Season Comforter (Full/Queen)
-
Best Down-Alternative Duvet Insert Overall: Quince Premium Down Alternative Comforter (Full/Queen)
-
Best Lightweight Down-Alternative Duvet Insert: Parachute Lightweight Down-Alternative Duvet Insert (Full/Queen)
-
Best Down-Alternative Comforter For Hot Sleepers: Buffy Cloud Comforter (Full/Queen)
-
Best Organic-Cotton Down-Alternative Duvet Insert: Coyuchi Climate Beneficial Cotton Duvet Insert (Full/Queen)
-
Best Down-Alternative Comforter on Amazon: Layla Down-Alternative Comforter (Full/Queen)
Best Down-Alternative Comforter Overall
Like Sleeping On A Cloud
Material: 100% cotton sateen shell, recycled fiber fill | Sizes: Twin/twin XL, full/queen, king/California king | Density: Lightweight, all-season or ultra-warm | Care: Spot cleaning recommended for small stains; otherwise, dry clean only
Pros:
- Comes in three different weights
- Has loops to attach to duvet
- Eco-conscious and made with sustainable materials
Cons:
- Dry clean only
- Sateen can easily look wrinkled
Brooklinen is the gold standard in the direct-to-consumer linens game. It’s known for producing responsibly manufactured textiles of exceptional quality for reasonable prices and providing standout customer service if you need to return anything. Believe it or not, the fill is made from recycled plastic bottles, but rest assured: These down-alternative comforters are some of the softest versions out there.
What our editors say: “The Brooklinen Down-Alternative Comforter has a really solid blend of fluffiness and coziness,” says senior sleep editor Bridget Chapman. “I have it in the all-season weight and haven’t felt the need to swap it out with something different as the weather changes—which is great, since sometimes I feel like my sleep body temperature is all over the place. It’s also pretty lightweight overall, so you can move around with ease at night.”
Best All-Season Down-Alternative Comforter
A Cuddly, Soft All-Season Option
Material: 100% cotton shell, cotton and Tencel fiber fill | Sizes: Queen and king | Density: All-season | Care: Dry clean only
Pros:
- Helps regulate temperature
- Has duvet loops
- Baffle-box construction
Cons:
- Dry clean only
The FluffCo Down-Alternative Comforter is an all-season option that’s made with a cotton-and-Tencel filling. It’s perfect for keeping you at the right temperature all year long, and customers rave about its ability to help regulate temperature. The baffle-box construction within the comforter helps the fill stay in place and prevents it from bunching up at the bottom or sides. Each corner has a loop for a duvet cover and you can grab a queen size for less than $150 when it’s on sale.
What our editors and the reviews say: Francesca Sales, an updates writer at Forbes Vetted, says, “I used a regular down comforter with my partner before the FluffCo Down-Alternative Comforter. While I didn’t mind the former in the winter, I like that this one is truly temperature regulating, so I don’t get too hot or too cold in it. It’s also incredibly fluffy and lighter-weight than a down one, so I love snuggling in it while reading a book or watching TV in bed. It also doesn’t bunch up like my old comforter.” One reviewer says, “Keeps me warm and cool if I need to be. I usually just keep one leg out of the blanket, and it’s perfect.” Another shopper praises it, saying, “So soft and warm, just the right temp. Temperature regulating. Highly recommend.”
Warmest Down-Alternative Comforter
Ultra Warm And Great For Cold Sleepers
Material: 100% combed cotton sateen shell, recycled polyester fill | Sizes: Twin/twin XL, full, queen, king/California king | Density: Light, medium, extra, ultra | Care: Machine wash cold on gentle cycle, tumble dry low
Pros:
- Available in four different warmth levels
- Has duvet loops
- Baffled construction prevents fill from shifting
Cons:
- Some reviewers don’t think it’s substantial enough
The Company Store has an excellent reputation for all things bedding. Made with an exclusive recycled polyester fill that’s designed to imitate the feel of actual down, the brand’s ultra warm down-alternative comforter option is made for “I run cold all the time” sleepers. Four warmth levels make it easy to find an option that suits the temperature in your bedroom: light (69 to 74 degrees), medium (65 to 69 degrees), extra-warm (62 to 65 degrees) and ultra-warm (62 degrees or colder).
What the reviews say: “We love this down-alternative duvet for our bed,” writes one reviewer. “It’s not too heavy and provides the right level of warmth (which is great, as my husband tends to sleep hot, and I tend to sleep cool).” Another says, “I needed to replace my comforter and decided to spend a little more money and purchase this one. It is worth the money and keeps you warm without being real heavy. It is perfect.”
Best Value Down-Alternative Comforter
An Affordable All-Season Comforter
Material: 100% polyester, polyester fill | Sizes: Twin, full/queen, king | Density: All-season | Care: Machine wash on cold
Pros:
- Budget-friendly option
- Available in two different quilting patterns
- Oeko-Tex certified
Cons:
- Only available in one warmth level
Puredown makes both down and down-alternative bedding at accessible prices. The brand has succeeded with this all-season comforter that’s under $100—perfect for anyone trying to stay on a budget. It’s constructed of 100% polyester fill wrapped in a 100% polyester cover for ultimate coziness. Plus, it’s machine washable on cold and available in two different quilting patterns. It’s also Standard 100 Oeko-Tex certified, indicating a high level of safety.
What the reviews say: “It is warm and cozy, no problem with allergies and overall a great comforter. I highly recommend this product.,” says one reviewer. Another writes, “I am very pleased with this comforter. It is well-made and looks good. It’s the perfect weight for coastal North Carolina fall and winter.”
Best Midweight Down-Alternative Comforter
Temperature Regulating For That Just-Right Feel
Sijo Clima Tech TempTune All Season Comforter (Full/Queen)
Material: Tencel lyocell fiber and mica nylon shell, Tencel lyocell and recycled polyester fill | Sizes: Full/queen, king/California king | Density: All-season | Care: Dry clean
Pros:
- Temperature regulating
- Hidden snaps and ties for a tidy finish
Cons:
- Dry clean only
Sijo’s down-alternative comforter is made with a patented blend of fibers that absorbs and distributes body heat to maintain a comfortable sleeping temperature. That means it’s cooling when you’re too warm and warming when you’re cold, making it ideal for year-round use. Interior snaps and ties keep this comforter secure if you’re using it with a duvet cover. The brand’s TempTune collection has FSC and Oeko-Tex certifications, so it’s also an eco-friendly pick. One drawback—the brand recommends dry cleaning.
What the reviews say: “This blanket is light, not heavy, but it keeps me so warm,” writes one reviewer. “The blanket is just right—warm but not too hot. My partner and I are both warm bodies when we sleep, but we didn’t sweat under this cover.” Another says, “I am typically a hot sleeper, and this is the perfect weight duvet for all seasons. The area I am in recently had the coldest day on record, and this duvet still kept me warm during the cold nights.”
Best Down-Alternative Duvet Insert Overall
Available In Three Weight Options
Material: 100% cotton sateen cover, microfiber fill | Sizes: Twin, full/queen, king/California king | Density: Lightweight, all-season, ultra warm | Care: Machine wash cold on gentle cycle, tumble dry
Pros:
- Available in three different weights
- Outer cover material is soft cotton sateen fabric
- Machine washable
Cons:
- Some reviewers say it’s very warm
The Quince Premium Down-Alternative Comforter is filled with hypoallergenic microfiber that mimics luxurious down fill. The baffle-box construction keeps the fill from shifting, and it’s available in three weights—lightweight, all-season and ultra warm—so you stay comfortable whether you sleep hot or cold. We like that the shell is 100% cotton sateen so the fabric is breathable and soft. If you want to use this as a duvet insert, it has four corner loops to keep a cover in place. One thing to note: You may want to go down a warmth level since some reviewers commented it’s very warm.
What the reviews say: One 5-star review says, “This is exactly the comforter I was hoping for. It’s lightweight, but quality material. I appreciate the loops at the corners to attach the duvet cover.” Another writes, “We are so happy with the comforter. It’s a perfect weight without being too hot (or cold) and still feels soft and cozy. Purchased this along with the linen duvet. The comforter fills out the duvet without leaving the annoying side gaps that are all fabric and no comforter.”
Best Lightweight Down-Alternative Duvet Insert
Light But Doesn’t Skimp On Coziness
Similar Posts
9 Of The Best Jeans For Curvy Women, From High-Waisted To Petite Inseam Styles
Like many curvy women, I’ve always had a hard time finding jeans—they either gap in the waistband or are too tight in the hips. But my picks for the best jeans for curvy women do neither. For example, my favorite pair overall, the NYDJ Marilyn Straight Jeans have a flattering fit and cut, while my…
The Best All-In-One Printers To Handle All Of Your Printing Needs
The best all-in-one printers are versatile multitaskers that can print, scan, copy and fax in one convenient package that doesn’t take up much space in your home office. Our overall favorite is the HP OfficeJet Pro 9125e, a simple, but nicely designed printer that can handle everything from business letters to homework. But if you’re…
The Best Smart Lights To Add Some Pizzazz To Your Home
Before the year 1879, a reliable, effective electric light was the thing of imagination, and the after sunset, the world remained lit only by fire. Then, in the fall of that year, Thomas Edison finally achieved what many others had also been striving for: the creation of a truly functional incandescent light bulb. Flash forward…
The Best Kids Water Shoes To Protect Little Feet And Stop Slipping
The beach is a natural playground for kids, but the rocks and shells that come with it can do a number on little feet. The best kids water shoes provide underfoot protection while allowing your child to move freely, in and out of the surf. Our top pick is the Keen Newport H2 water sandals…
The Best Firm Mattress Toppers For Added Support And Better Sleep
There are a few tell-tale signs your mattress is too soft: you wake up with back pain, struggle to get out of bed or there are obvious lumps and sags present. If your mattress still has life in it, our best firm mattress topper picks can help you get a better, more comfortable sleep, without…
The Best Mirrorless Cameras To Capture Images And Videos Forever
Mirrorless cameras are the rising stars of digital photography, with the latest technologies that make it easier than ever to capture images in the most challenging shooting situations. The best mirrorless cameras—like our overall pick, the Sony A7 IV—are incredibly versatile for both stills and video. Many of these models hold appeal for amateur, enthusiast…